An up-to-date estimate of the variety of unlawful immigrants in the UK has not been produced for 15 years, based on a report.
The Nationwide Audit Workplace (NAO) mentioned the final estimate in 2005 instructed there have been round 430,000 folks within the nation with no proper to stay.
However unbiased analysis since has put the determine at a couple of million, Whitehall’s spending watchdog mentioned.
The NAO’s report into the Dwelling Workplace’s immigration enforcement directorate mentioned the division had estimated demand for immigration enforcement exercise.
This was put at between 240,000 and 320,000 circumstances a yr.
However the report mentioned there was no baseline given towards which progress may be measured or to reveal whether or not demand is rising or falling.
The watchdog concluded that regardless of amassing info round its mission and targets, the Dwelling Workplace usually can not reveal whether or not its measures are working.
Within the yr to October 2019, detected makes an attempt by folks to return into the UK by clandestine means elevated to 46,900.
Nevertheless, the NAO mentioned it was not clear if this was as a result of extra makes an attempt have been being made or if there was higher detection.
:: Hearken to the Each day podcast on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Spreaker
Its report added that the Dwelling Workplace is just not in a position to assess whether or not its measures to cease folks accessing government-funded companies “have any significant influence on the chance that a person will go away the UK voluntarily”.
The watchdog mentioned the Dwelling Workplace might “enhance its understanding of the total scale of the unlawful inhabitants within the UK and determine new methods to handle a number of the challenges it faces” by how different components of presidency produce estimates of “hidden exercise”.
A Pew Analysis Centre estimate final yr put the inhabitants of unlawful immigrants within the UK at 1.2 million, however the NAO mentioned it had not tried to confirm that determine.
“Though there can be important uncertainty round any estimate it [the department] developed, such an estimate might assist the division to reveal that its actions are efficient in deterring makes an attempt to enter or stay within the UK illegally,” the report mentioned.
Meg Hillier, chairwoman of the Commons Public Accounts Committee, mentioned the evaluation demonstrated that the Dwelling Workplace “has no concept how many individuals are within the nation illegally and would not appear fascinated with discovering out”.
The Labour MP added: “It might probably’t reveal that its actions to manage unlawful immigration are working as supposed, and would not perceive how completely different points of its work match collectively.”
NAO head Gareth Davies mentioned that immigration enforcement was “by its very nature” a “advanced and difficult” job.
“Whereas the Dwelling Workplace has launched important modifications to its enforcement exercise, it can not reveal that total efficiency is enhancing,” he added.
“The division wants a greater understanding of the influence of its immigration enforcement exercise on its overarching imaginative and prescient to scale back the scale of the unlawful inhabitants and the hurt it causes.”
A Dwelling Workplace spokesman mentioned: “We now have taken again management of our immigration system and for the primary time in a era, we can have full management over who comes and stays right here.
“As this report acknowledges, the character of immigration crime and offending is sophisticated and we’re persistently methods to get forward of the organised gangs behind it.
“We work tirelessly with worldwide companions and companies, such because the NCA, to sort out unlawful migration, shut down routes for folks smuggling and return these with no proper to stay within the UK wherever doable.
“We make no apology for in search of to deport international nationwide offenders and since 2010 now we have eliminated greater than 53,000 criminals.”